Risky business at the DMNews Creative Jam

Share this article:
"Risk" was the word of the day at the DMNews Creative Jam today -- used by everyone from keynote speakers to roundtable participants. This particular roundtable participant was no exception.

I sat in on a Creative Jam Session moderated by John Palisay, VP and creative director, Draftfcb. Our topic, "The Ethics and Standards of Risk," proved a difficult one to grasp in the mere 45 minutes we were given. Participants all had a different definition for "risk," and almost all had different definitions for "ethics" as well (a bit disconcerting), but the trickiest part of the discussion was figuring out how the two concepts overlap, or should.

Is it ethical for an agency to put interesting creative first, thus possibly taking a risk with a company's brand? Is it ethical for a company to go along with a potentially offensive idea presented by the agency? How do you make interesting marketing messages that convey a company's ethical standards? How many buttons, and which ones, can you push to walk that line between building interest and building public ire?

Many of our button-pushing examples focused on portrayals of sex and sexuality. Is it ethical for Unilever to market Dove under a pro-women banner and objectify them for Axe ads? When both campaigns are such wild successes, does it matter?

Of course, in all matters, it's important to be ethical. Responsible agencies and their clients know that. But it's also important to take risks. Risks and ethics are not mutually exclusive. In fact, some of our Jam Session participants argued that, if you're not taking risks, you're not doing your job as an agency. It's up to agencies and their clients to figure out which lines to walk and which to cross.
Share this article:
You must be a registered member of Direct Marketing News to post a comment.
close

Next Article in Direct Line Blog

Sign up to our newsletters

Latest Jobs:


Company of the week

Data Services, Inc. meets the needs of today's data-driven marketer by providing front-end database management and data analytics platforms alongside our expertise in global contact data quality, database building and ongoing maintenance that comes with our 45+ years in business.


Find out more here »

More in Direct Line Blog

Big Data Enables Bigger (and Hopefully Better) Campaigns

Big Data Enables Bigger (and Hopefully Better) Campaigns

Almost any dataset can improve the effectiveness of a marketing campaign—if used creatively and nimbly.

Stop Wasting Marketing Dollars on Poor Customer Experiences

Stop Wasting Marketing Dollars on Poor Customer Experiences

An open letter to the C-suite on the importance of remembering what it's like to be your customer.

9 "New and Improved" Tools for Customer Engagement

9 "New and Improved" Tools for Customer Engagement

Salesforce ExactTarget Marketing Cloud launches a bevy of products at Connections 2014.