Marketing Challenge: When a Counteroffer Is as Risky as a Good-bye

Share this article:
Marketing Challenge: When a Counteroffer Is as Risky as a Good-bye
Marketing Challenge: When a Counteroffer Is as Risky as a Good-bye

As Juan Paolo told Dana Jerry the news, all she could do was blink in disbelief. Paolo was giving two week's notice. But he wasn't leaving to go to a competitor. No. He was leaving to run marketing for the company that had been his number one client during his tenure as a creative director for Modesto Marketing Services. Ace Products CEO Carl Shumer had made Paolo quite a generous offer: 20% pay increase, performance bonus, three week's vacation, and his own executive assistant.

This situation wasn't uncommon in the agency business. Jerry had lost other creatives to their clients, and knew plenty of other agency executives who faced the same circumstances. This situation was different because Paolo was so highly regarded by all of his clients. Jerry was consumed with worry that his clients would launch an agency search, forcing Modesto to compete for its existing business.

Jerry stammered out an attempt at an enthusiastic congratulations and then asked Paolo not to share the news until she could speak with him later that day.

Alone in her office Jerry considered her options. Should she make a counteroffer? Would she then lose Ace as a client? (Would she lose Ace anyway?) Should she simply wish Paolo well and launch a proactive initiative to retain his clients? There was no easy answer.

What would you do?

Click here to see what our readers had to say.

This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed in any form without prior authorization. Your use of this website constitutes acceptance of Haymarket Media's Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions