Letter: Since When Is 'No Thanks, I'm Not Interested' an Infringement of Free Speech?

Regarding Tad Clarke's editorial ("Without Information, There Is No Information Age," May 2) and the recent dust-up over ChoicePoint, et al., a primary missing ingredient in the information business is the total absence of a "feedback loop." The consumer's feedback is fundamentally excluded from the data collection process.

From my perspective as a consumer, the industry has been entirely uncontrolled for so long that it actually believes any attempt from a - gag, choke, cough! - consumer to express THEIR preferences is a restriction of the constitutional rights of free speech of industry.

Since when is "No thanks, I'm not interested" an infringement of free speech?

What am I to think when I get my credit reports and find that: (1) they list me as having lived at a wrong address, and (2) the last employment they list is 25-plus years ago. The worst part is I know where the wrong address came from, and there is no legitimate reason for a credit bureau to have picked up such data.

Another good one (since corrected) was jumbling my ZIP code. Three years after a ZIP code change, two of the credit agencies couldn't figure out which ZIP code I lived in, so they reported both.

When I can easily see such mistakes/sloppy reporting, as a data professional I worry about the information that I can't see.

Do a little experiment: Ask random people on the street two questions:

1. Have you heard of the Direct Marketing Association?

2. Have you heard of (or used) the DMA's Mail Preference System?

My experience is that maybe 1 in 10 knows who/what the DMA is. And maybe 1 in 10 of those (we're down to 1 percent now) is aware of the MPS.

A common response to the natural third question ("Do you get too much unwanted mail?") is "No ... I just throw it away." Think about that.

David Eddy, Babson Park, MA


This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed in any form without prior authorization. Your use of this website constitutes acceptance of Haymarket Media's Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions