Letter: 'Back of Book' Mentality Contributes to Negative Stereotypes

Share this article:
A final word (at least from me) on the "Caples Controversy." In last week's letters section, Mark Everett Johnson bragged that he created "one of the ugliest pieces of advertising ever mailed" and then went on to detail its success.


That's all well and good for advertisers who exist in a world where brand image has no salience. But what about an auto manufacturer? A clothing maker? A package goods brand? Or countless other marketers who are "discovering" direct? Should we tell them to just go away? Or to mail or run schlock and forget branding altogether? This "back of the book," "junk mail" mentality contributes to the negative stereotypes long associated with direct.


I, along with many, many other creatives, labor long and hard to craft direct that is tasteful, engaging and, yes, even welcome in people's homes - all to generate a high rate of response. And while creatives like myself do so for personal gain (winning a Caples), we are at the same time elevating the industry and contributing to its growth. "A rising tide lifts all boats," says the adage. Excuse me while I run to patch a few leaks created by the advocates of ugly.


Steven DiManni, Senior vice president, creative director, McCaffery, Ratner, Gottlieb & Lane, Board member, John Caples International Awards


sdimanni@mrgl.net


Share this article:

Sign up to our newsletters

Follow us on Twitter @dmnews

Latest Jobs:

More in Opinions

The Challenge of Changeable Customers

The Challenge of Changeable Customers

When it comes to behavioral targeting, I'm never surprised by the ads I'm served on my personal Mac.

Spoiled for Choice: Answers

Spoiled for Choice: Answers

Sterling Worldwide is hiring a new VP of sales and marketing. Should the CRM expert or the data person get the job? See what our readers has to say.

Peering Into the Marketing Future

Peering Into the Marketing Future

You've heard it many times before: The only constant is change. Not really. Sometimes, the only constant is stubborn resistance. This year we'll see a mix of both.