It's Not Which Lists Are Better, But Which Are More Appropriate for the Application

Share this article:
I understand Vin Gupta's frustration with the negative industry image of compiled lists. Rightly or wrongly, compiled lists have taken on a second-class status in the eyes of many direct marketing professionals.

But as someone who rents both compiled and response/circulation lists for my clients, I don't think it's an issue of which lists are better - but which lists are more appropriate for the application.

Response and circulation lists help you reach proven buyers and responders to offers that are similar to yours. They help you reach prospects who, through their own actions, have demonstrated an interest in a particular subject, product, discipline or industry.

Response and circulation lists are usually your best options, but only if your geographic market is broad enough to produce a sufficient quantity. I often have clients with a target market of a single town, county or state, or even a few states - and response and circulation lists (which usually have a national audience) just won't do. To get a decent saturation, you need compiled lists.

I also find compiled lists to be the best choice when my audience profile is comprised primarily of demographic data - on the business side, SICs, employee size, sales volume; on the consumer side, age, income, family size. Once psychographic data enter into the profile, however, I start to look elsewhere.

As for the cost differential, I never let price be a factor in choosing lists. The list is far too important to the program, and it still only represents about 20 percent of the overall cost.

Bob McCarthy, McCarthy & King Marketing Inc.,

Share this article:
You must be a registered member of Direct Marketing News to post a comment.

Sign up to our newsletters

Follow us on Twitter @dmnews

Latest Jobs:

More in Opinions

When Marketing and Sales Collide: Answers

When Marketing and Sales Collide: Answers

The head of marketing operations is doing just as much selling as marketing, sans the commission her sales colleagues earn. How should she handle it? See how our readers would ...

App of the Week: RescueTime

App of the Week: RescueTime

RescueTime aims to help users become more focused and productive.

Defending Direct: Answers

Defending Direct: Answers

Miranda Bell knows her program will pay off but CEO Dasha Atwala says to nix it. What should she do?

Copyright © 2014 Haymarket Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed in any form without prior authorization.
Your use of this website constitutes acceptance of Haymarket Media's Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions.