Is reach or response more important?

Share this article:
The gloves are off
The gloves are off

As media continue to fragment, two experts debate whether it is more important to achieve high response rates through targeted campaigns, or a large audience through a wide-reaching media buy.



CONTENDER
Olivier Chaine
CEO and founder of Magnify360
Founder of The Marketing Architects; former VP at LowerMyBills.com

Response rate always trumps broad reach. Broad reach campaigns generate low response rates, poor qual­ity traffic and don't provide the deeper insights needed for future campaigns.

Marketers are better served gaining broad reach through a pyramid of tar­geted campaigns, each stacked upon the insights of the previous one. The quality of customers that are gained through targeted media is what drives higher response rates and higher returns.

In addition to driving future cam­paigns, the value of the intelligence gathered from a niche audience can drive better creative, offers and, often, new products. By understanding the trends and profiles from targeted cam­paigns, marketers can easily find other sources of inexpensive media, like offline advertising, banners or e-mail.

For example, a sporting goods company, running a search campaign around sports equipment and activi­ties, finds a concentrated segment of early adopter/gadget geeks. Next, I would recommend building a display advertising campaign on Gizmodo or Engadget, featuring GPS watches and waterproof MP3 players. This will drive a much higher response rate and ROI than casting a wide net. With the evolution of ad network technology, marketing automation and testing tools, marketers can target display, e-mail, mobile and offline efforts to achieve the results they need.


CONTENDER
Sandeep Kharidhi
VP of analytics and marketing strategy at ChoicePoint Preci­sion Marketing
Former VP of DM for Wachovia

For most direct marketing cam­paigns, a case can be made that high response rates are more important than broad reach. After all, poor response rates almost always ensure an unsuc­cessful campaign. But response rates alone give no indication as to the cost per response, the resulting conversion rate, or the overall campaign profitabil­ity, each of which is just as important in determining the success of a campaign.

A marketer's primary focus should be on response rates only when justifiable from a campaign cost vs. new revenue obtained perspective. An example could be a retailer launching a direct sales channel to augment in-store sales. Most direct marketers fall into this “required cost justification” category.

Alternatively, some campaigns are used primarily for increasing brand awareness and therefore broad reach is the overriding objective. Consider direct-to-consumer marketers of auto insurance who use direct channels to build and maintain brand awareness. A consumer may not be in the market for auto insurance today, but eventually he or she will be. Brand awareness then becomes paramount. Furthermore, the channel many consumers use for purchase may not be the same channel most successful in reaching them.

The cost of reach must be aligned with response rates and conversion rates so that both total revenue objectives and profitability objectives are achieved.

DMNews' DECISION
The experts agree that response rates are fundamental to a good cam­paign. However, Kharidhi notes that they are only one part of a valuable equation. He points out that some consumers use several channels to make a purchase decision, and a wider net snares more potential buyers. Direct marketers must weigh a targeted message with overall growth goals.


Hav
e your say: E-mail your view to cara.wood@dmnews.com  

Share this article:
You must be a registered member of Direct Marketing News to post a comment.
close

Next Article in Multichannel Marketing

Sign up to our newsletters

Follow us on Twitter @dmnews

Latest Jobs:

More in Multichannel Marketing

Complexity's What Marketers Got, Simplicity's What They Want

Complexity's What Marketers Got, Simplicity's What They Want

Customer insights managers want campaign management tools to remain easy to use, even as they up their games with multi-layered campaigns.

Wine.com Uncorks New Digital Marketing Opportunities

Wine.com Uncorks New Digital Marketing Opportunities

The online wine retailer's strategy incorporates different flavors and depths.

93% of Companies Are Ineffective at Cross-Channel Marketing

93% of Companies Are Ineffective at Cross-Channel Marketing ...

Companies point to a lack of resources as the most common reason for lackluster marketing integration, a study says.