Google may rule the world, but is its direct mail a banana republic?

Share this article:

Direct mail, as is so often the case with the established and the tried-and-true, continues to get a bad rap for being tired, uncreative and yesterday's news.

Try telling that to Hearst Magazines president Michael Clinton, who recently told us that not only is print his company's core business, it remains an integral part of its direct marketing strategy, with an estimated 70 million pieces of direct mail slated to go out in 2012 – and that's only for new customer solicitations.

As Brian Fetherstonhaugh, chairman and CEO of OgilvyOne Worldwide, points out in a column in Direct Marketing News this month, $56 billion is spent on direct mail in the U.S. while less than $40 billion is spent on search, display, email and mobile advertising combined. OgilvyOne's top 20 clients all use direct mail in their marketing mix, he notes.

Even the biggest players in the digital sphere understand the power of print. This month, Google executed a direct mail promotion in England inviting the recipient to try out Google AdWords and including an incentive worth £75 for executing a campaign using the platform. It's also made use of direct mail offers in other markets, including the U.S.

Still, one agency dude who got the U.K. mailer couldn't have been less impressed if somebody had sent him a day-old scone.

Taking to the marketing and media news site The Drum, Simon Robinson, integrated creative director for agency Kitcatt Nohr Digitas, wrote an opinion piece ridiculing Google's mailer for failing to elicit that all-important “wow” factor. He writes that “there is something fundamentally amazing about Google using the least fashionable of all marketing media to promote itself,” arguing that while the mailer possesses many hallmarks of a worthy direct campaign – it's targeted, it's personalized, it's designed to drive a response – “it just isn't creative.”

Which brings us back to that age-old question of direct marketing: Is it the creative or the deal that drives response?

In a recent conversation, Tim Suther, CMO of marketing services firm Acxiom Corp., had plenty to say about the power of direct mail as both a creative medium and an awareness and response vehicle – and on a global scale.

“As much grief as direct mail sometimes gets in the U.S., in emerging geographies it works quite well. It has a richness in creative you cannot get in Internet advertising and it does not have the expense of TV,” he explains. “If your goal is awareness and having something that is a little durable in its call-to-action, mail is an effective technique.”

Let's face it. While its image may be less than sexy, direct mail is no different than any other marketing vehicle: Some creatives get it right, while others lack inspiration, or the power to inspire. And size doesn't necessarily matter. As no less than Google illustrates, sometimes the bigger they come, the harder they fail.

Share this article:
You must be a registered member of Direct Marketing News to post a comment.

Next Article in Direct Line Blog

Sign up to our newsletters

Latest Jobs:

Company of the week

Data Services, Inc. meets the needs of today's data-driven marketer by providing front-end database management and data analytics platforms alongside our expertise in global contact data quality, database building and ongoing maintenance that comes with our 45+ years in business.

Find out more here »

More in Direct Line Blog

Creative Marketing Is Good; Useful, Relevant Messages Are Better

Creative Marketing Is Good; Useful, Relevant Messages Are ...

The next wave of the digital evolution is pushing marketers toward hyper-relevance; but not everyone is catching on.

What (Truly) Matters to Millennials

What (Truly) Matters to Millennials

A recent study reveals the things that millennials really care about—and what moves them to make a purchase.

The Long, Hard Road to Marketing Sophistication

The Long, Hard Road to Marketing Sophistication

If there are times when you feel like you're way behind on the customer journey, well, you probably are. But so is nearly everyone else.