Direct Line Blog

GM gives Zuck a slap in the Facebook

Share this article:
GM's Facebook cover ... not much else to say about that.
GM's Facebook cover ... not much else to say about that.

The Wall Street Journal broke the story at 2:52 pm on Tuesday, May 15 with a tweet: “GM to stop buying ads on Facebook, sees them as ineffective.” Dare I say, the tweet heard round the world. It was actually only a rumor at that point (General Motors didn't confirm until several hours later), but the news caught fire immediately, as of course it would.

GM — the third biggest advertiser in the U.S., behind P&G and AT&T  — isn't going to stop marketing on Facebook. It's just going to stop paying Facebook for the privilege of doing so. The automaker still plans to maintain its page, where it has more than 378,000 “likes.” That, of course, is free. Well, free for regular people, not marketing behemoths. According to the Journal, GM expends about $30 million a year on agencies to develop its Facebook content and on staff to maintain the page.

Joel Ewanick, GM's head of marketing, proffered this rather bland statement to the press regarding the company's decision: GM is “definitely reassessing our advertising on Facebook, although content is effective and important.”

What GM spent on Facebook ads — just $10 million — was only a tiny fraction of its total marketing budget. Considering Kantar Media estimates the company dropped $1.8 billion on advertising in 2011, that's about as noticeable as a fly on an elephant's rear.

What this means for Facebook's long-awaited, highly anticipated, much-discussed and extensively pondered upcoming IPO is on the mind of every blogger, analyst, journalist, marketer and investor from here to, say, China — the only country in the world other than India whose population is still higher than the number of Facebook users: over 900 million.

However a marketer feels about the usefulness of Facebook ads, it's unwise to ignore a website that has more active users than almost triple the population of the United States. But Facebook doesn't hold all the power. If other large advertisers decide to chuck FB ads, Facebook could be cooked, as the Friending Facebook blog on ZDNet rightly points out.

How often do Facebook users really click on those ads in the right-hand column? One of my coworkers told me she was able to track down a service she was looking for through a Facebook ad, so for her it worked like a charm. But 57% of users polled by AP/CNBC in a recent survey said they never click on paid ads or sponsored content when they're on Facebook. [CNBC posted the results of the poll on Facebook. Both meta and cheeky.]

For a company like Facebook — the Journal says the majority of Facebook's $3.7 billion annual revenue comes from sales — that is certainly unpleasant news.

As for me, the effectiveness of Facebook ads is zero. I've never clicked on a single one.

 
Allison Schiff
is web editor at
Direct Marketing News.

(Zuckerberg image credit: zipmeme.com/)

Share this article:

Sign up to our newsletters

Latest Jobs:


Company of the week


Concerned about growth? With over 25 years experience in the industry, the list experts at Fairfield Marketing Group possess the know-how to help immediately improve any domestic or international direct marketing effort. First-time and well-established mailers can rely on Fairfield Marketing Group's expertise to help launch campaigns into positive and profitable ventures.

Find out more here »

More in Direct Line Blog

In a World of Technological Novelty, Execution Prevails

In a World of Technological Novelty, Execution Prevails

A successful business and marketing strategy needn't rely on unique ideas so much as exceptional execution of any idea, a marketing expert says.

Is 5-Day Delivery USPS's Way of Saying It's Giving Up on Mail?

Is 5-Day Delivery USPS's Way of Saying It's ...

The head of the PRC and a noted union leader think so. They wonder why such an exclusive business isn't 24/7 instead.

Président Replaces Cheesy TV Spots with Digital

Président Replaces Cheesy TV Spots with Digital

Marketing + Cheese: What more could you want?