Let's talk

Virgin Trains recently made a pretty big mistake, and I want to hear your opinions, DMers.

The company sent out an e-mail offering a "Five star evening at The Grove" (a golf resort in Hertfordshire), worth about $780. Sounds nice, right?

The mistake: they sent it to their entire customer database. The message, it seems, was actually just a test run, intended for three staff members. Eventually, it was supposed to go out to a small group of top-tier customers as a loyalty bonus.

The solution: Virgin Trains sent out a follow-up e-mail retracting the offer. It was polite: “So sorry, we’ve sent you an email by mistake. The email you have just received about a Virgin Trains event at The Grove was a test email and was not supposed to be sent to any of our customers.
“We realise that we might have got you all excited about the prospect of a day at The Grove, and would like to offer you the chance to win one of three places at this event.”

Is this good enough?

I don't know that there was any clean way for Virgin Trains to get out of this one; it's one of those mistakes that should just never happen in the first place. The good: The apologetic tone was nice, and the fact that they turned the gaff into something "fun" (a contest! wheee!) was a creative touch. The bad: I feel like an e-mail can come off as too breezy, an after-thought, but where do you get the funds and man-power to contact everyone in a more "personal" way? The ugly: I imagine that, whatever anyone does in this situation, they're still going to have to deal with a number of irate, disappointed and possibly litigious customers.

So here's where you, readers, come in:
How would you/ do you prevent something like this from happening in the first place?

And, once the cat's out of the bag, how do you deal with it? Is the contest a good idea? The retraction e-mail?

Send us your wisdom, please, along with a ticket for a free day at the Grove, if you have one.
You must be a registered member of Direct Marketing News to post a comment.

Next Article in Direct Line Blog

Sign up to our newsletters

Company of the Week

SK&A is a leading provider of U.S. healthcare information solutions and databases. As part of IMS Health, SK&A researches and maintains contact and profiling data for over 2 million healthcare providers, including 800,000+ prescribers. SK&A's data supports research and marketing initiatives for life sciences, medical device, managed healthcare, direct marketing, publishing, education and more. SK&A's proprietary databases are telephone-verified twice per year from its world class Research Centers. SK&A enables multi-channel marketing and sets the standard for data quality and reliability. SK&A's customers include many of America's most recognized healthcare, publishing and pharmaceutical institutions.

Featured Listings



SK&A is a leading provider of U.S. healthcare information solutions and databases. As ...