EDITORIAL: Network Ownership Not Absolute

Share this content:
There are deeply troubling premises in the arguments of anti-spam group Mail Abuse Prevention System LLC founder Paul Vixie concerning the implications of network ownership and fully verified opt-in e-mail marketing (see MAPS Only Verified Opt-In Is True Opt-In, http://www.dmnews.com/articles/2000-08-14/9891.html). The ownership argument contends, at the risk of oversimplification, that networks are private property and therefore their owners have every right to determine who can and cannot send mail across them.

The Internet is analogous to a national highway system, but sections of it are maintained by private parties.

This system was begun with tax dollars, which, unless some magical source has recently appeared, generally result from commerce. With that in mind, the anti-commerce tone of those who have been involved in the Internet since its earliest days has always been difficult to stomach.

As for the absolute ownership argument, it's difficult to imagine any sane person would argue that, say, if a neo-Nazi owned a network, he could block e-mail from people with Jewish-sounding names.

So obviously the network ownership argument is not absolute.

Meanwhile, the e-mail system has become a necessity for conducting business in the United States.

As a result, owning a network is a de facto pact with far more than just the network's subscribers.

Few in mainstream marketing argue for spam. It pollutes the marketplace. The recent debate with MAPS and its followers has been over the nuances of opt-in e-mail address collection.

Vixie's argument is the equivalent of saying, "Only horse-drawn carriages are allowed on my highway. It's not up to us to adapt to the automobile. It's up to the new drivers to adapt to us. After all, it was our culture long before auto drivers came onto the scene."

Nonsense. Never mind that this system became a highway because of these auto drivers.

Also, Vixie's argument for allowing only the so-called gold standard of fully verified opt-in hinges mainly on the claim that he has been "forge-subscribed" to sometimes hundreds of e-mail lists in a single weekend. So the rest of us are supposed to adapt our business practices because Vixie -- probably the best-known anti-spam advocate in the world -- has been the victim of spam pranksters? Please.

What's more, dictating that fully verified opt-in is the only acceptable practice interferes with the mutually consensual business relationships of those who still practice opt-in, but at less-stringent levels -- certainly room for a lawsuit there.

It shouldn't be up to the rest of the world to conform to the odd anti-commercial culture that has evolved because the Net began as mainly an academic toy.

But as long as network owners are able to lord over their fiefdoms like myopic fairy-tale trolls guarding bridges, it seems highly unlikely that a commerce-friendly compromise will evolve for mainstream e-mail marketers.

Next Article in Digital Marketing

Sign up to our newsletters

Company of the Week

We recently were named B2B Magazine's Direct Marketing Agency of the Year, and with good reason: We make real, measureable, positive change happen for our clients. A full-service agency founded in 1974, Bader Rutter expertly helps you get the right message to the right audience at the right time through the right channels. As we engage our clients' audiences along their journey, direct marketing (email, direct mail, phone, SMS) and behavioral marketing (SEM, retargeting, contextual) channels deliver information relevant to the needs of each stage. We are experts at implementing and leveraging marketing technologies such as CRM and marketing automation in order to synchronize sales and marketing communications. Our team of architects and activators plan, execute, measure and adjust in real time to ensure the strategy is working as needed and change things if it's not.

Find out more here »

Career Center

Check out hundreds of exciting professional opportunities available on DMN's Career Center.  
Explore careers in digital marketing, sales, eCommerce, marketing communications, IT, data strategies, and much more. And don't forget to update your resume so employers can contact you privately about job opportunities.

>>Click Here

Relive the 2017 Marketing Hall of Femme

Click the image above