**Court Dismisses Consumer Case Against Publishers Clearing House

Share this article:
Publishers Clearing House said yesterday that the U.S. District Court in Ohio dismissed a case brought by an individual who alleged that a PCH mailing constituted a contract to award him a $10 million prize.


U.S. District Court Judge Dan Aaron Polster granted the company's motion to dismiss the case of Dan Thomas v. PCH.


A spokesman for PCH, Port Washington, NY, said Polster dismissed the case because there were many clear messages and directions throughout the mailing indicating that it was not a contract.


In his decision, Polster said, "Thomas apparently chose to ignore this language, the [word] 'DRAFT' superimposed over both pages of the letter, and the Official Rules in order to determine that the mailing constituted a contract. .... Rather than establishing a contract, the mailing only shows that there was not a contract between the parties."


Christopher L. Irving, PCH's senior director of consumer affairs, said, "We are glad that this action has been dismissed at its earliest stage. … This decision is one in a long line in which courts continue to find that Publishers Clearing House mailings are clear and easy to understand to anyone who takes the time to read them."


Irving said a judge has ruled in the company's favor in the past 10 cases in which a court has considered the merits of a PCH sweepstakes claim.


PCH will award its next major prize of $1 million in a live PCH announcement in a commercial during NBC Nightly News with Tom Brokaw on Aug. 24.
Share this article:

Sign up to our newsletters

Follow us on Twitter @dmnews

Latest Jobs:

More in News

News Byte: Comcast Expanding Global Ad Delivery Through Partnership

News Byte: Comcast Expanding Global Ad Delivery Through ...

Through a partnership with Adstream , Comcast's AdDelivery Service expands its footprint across the globe.

40 Under 40 2014: Nominations Are Now Open!

40 Under 40 2014: Nominations Are Now Open!

It's time to nominate the 2014 crop of young marketing luminaries for Direct Marketing News's 40 Under 40 Awards. The deadline is Friday, June 6, 2014.

News Byte: MediaCrossing Partners with ASL Marketing on Youth Marketing Tool

News Byte: MediaCrossing Partners with ASL Marketing on ...

The digital media trading firm and marketing database company aim to help marketers target 13 to 34 year olds.